Chateaubriand vs. Filet Mignon: What's the Difference?

Val Watson
Authored by Val Watson
Posted Wednesday, January 24, 2024 - 10:08am

When it comes to indulging in the world of premium steak cuts, two names often rise to the top of the culinary echelon: Chateaubriand and Filet Mignon. Both are revered for their exceptional tenderness and succulent flavour, often gracing the tables of fine-dining restaurants and special occasion dinners. But despite their similarities, these two illustrious cuts are distinct in several crucial ways.

Origins: A Brief Background

The Royal Legacy of Chateaubriand

Chateaubriand is named after François-René de Chateaubriand, a French statesman and writer. Oddly enough, he didn't have a particular affiliation with the cut, but rather, his personal chef is credited with creating the dish in the early 19th century. The steak was cooked between two lesser cuts of meat to retain its juiciness, which were then discarded and the Chateaubriand served with a sauce made from white wine, shallots, and demi-glace.

Filet Mignon: The 'Cute Fillet'

Filet Mignon literally translates from French as 'cute fillet' or 'dainty fillet', underscoring its petite size and delicate nature. Unlike Chateaubriand, Filet Mignon doesn't have a historical narrative tied to its name. It has been a staple in French and American cuisine for many decades, appreciated for its leanness and tenderness.

The Cut: Where They Come From

Centre of Attention: Chateaubriand

Chateaubriand is sourced from the centre section of the tenderloin, the most tender part of the beef. Usually, the cut weighs between 10 to 12 ounces and is thick enough to serve two. The tenderloin runs along the spine, and it's a muscle that does very little work, hence its tenderness.

Petite but Powerful: Filet Mignon

Filet Mignon also hails from the tenderloin but is cut from the smaller end. It’s generally served as a 2- to 3-inch thick portion, weighing between 4 to 6 ounces. Unlike Chateaubriand, Filet Mignon is typically a serving for one.

Cooking Techniques: Searing, Roasting, Grilling

The Chateaubriand Experience

The larger size and thickness of Chateaubriand make it ideal for roasting. Often, it's seared first to lock in the juices and then oven-roasted to perfection. The result is a sumptuously juicy steak that can be carved at the table, offering an element of culinary theatre to your dining experience.

Simplicity at its Best: Filet Mignon

Filet Mignon is usually pan-seared, grilled, or even broiled. Due to its smaller size, it cooks quickly, so vigilance is key to avoid overcooking. Because it’s leaner, it’s often wrapped in bacon to add some fat, thereby enhancing the flavour.

The Sauce Affair: Classic Companions

The Indulgent Chateaubriand Sauce

Chateaubriand is traditionally served with a reduction sauce made from shallots, white wine, and demi-glace. The sauce complements the meat's rich flavour, making each bite a harmonious blend of complexity and subtlety.

The Versatile Filet Mignon

Filet Mignon, on the other hand, is versatile when it comes to sauces. From a simple garlic herb butter to a more elaborate Béarnaise, the choice of sauce can be tailored to personal preference, making Filet Mignon a culinary chameleon of sorts.

The Occasion: Setting the Scene

Chateaubriand: A Social Affair

Chateaubriand is often reserved for special occasions like anniversaries or celebratory events, mainly due to its larger size and the ritualistic carving at the table. It tends to be more of a 'showstopper', if you will.

Filet Mignon: Personal Indulgence

Filet Mignon is perfect for those moments when you desire a personal indulgence or when you’re dining solo. Its convenient size and quick cooking time make it a go-to for quality dining at home or eating out.

The Verdict: Both Worthy, But Distinct

In the end, choosing between Chateaubriand and Filet Mignon often comes down to the occasion, the number of people you're serving, and your preference for a particular cooking technique or sauce. While both cuts promise a tender, mouth-watering experience, their differences make each unique in its own right. Whether you opt for the socially inclined Chateaubriand or the individually tailored Filet Mignon, you're in for a culinary delight that speaks to the finer things in life.


Share this